Nerdy Prudes Must Die, Hollins University

 Hollins University Theatre, November 13-14, 7:30 pm, November 14, 2pm. Run time about 2.5 hours including one ten-minute intermission.

 When making plans this weekend, I read a quick synopsis of Nerdy Prudes Must Die and almost gave it a pass. I don't like horror, I don't want to laugh at people dying (of a wedgie?! um, what?), and well, I'm tired. Last night's production of The Welkin kept me up pretty late. (Totally worth it!)

But I am glad I did decide to attend Nerdy Prudes Must Die, a horror musical written by Jeff Blim, Matt and Nick Lang, and chosen by the Hollins theater majors as their senior project. I am here to encourage you to go see it too. Let me explain why.

At first I felt very much "on the outside." Hollins is a tight-knit community; the theater was full of exuberant young people; and I felt like an old fuddy duddy in the wrong place. I was barely able to scroll through the digital program (digital. ugh. I hate reading on my phone.) before the production began; the most I was able to glean was that this musical is part of a larger series written by people I'd never heard of and posted on Youtube or some such thing. Evidently Hollins had performed another musical from this series the year before, but I missed it. The musical started off with rollicking songs about hating high school, delineating the cliques that were excluding people, and it all seemed a little too cartoonish - though I definitely was feeling that "do I really belong here?" vibe myself.  

But this talented group of young people drew me in. Director Gwyn Lloyd (also a senior theater major) shepherded a lively and effective ensemble of actors into an entertaining and delightful production. From effective costumes (with exactly the right amount of glitter) to rousing choreography to over-the-top hilarious physical humor, the production value was high and the execution on point. Lloyd used the stage well, with scaffolding on the sides for extra lighting, many scenes played on the lip and into the house, and several characters' entrances from the back of the auditorium. The set was spare, but I like that in a theatrical production - let me use my imagination to fill in the gaps; all we need is a table or a bench. I wasn't a huge fan of the large background scrim with only a short riser in front of it - it often seemed a blank square dwarfing the actors in front of it - but it was a strong aesthetic choice, regardless. 

The sound was a barrier to my engagement. It was far too difficult to decipher people's words, whether talking or singing - but especially while singing. The recorded background music was often too loud and drowned out the singers. Thankfully, strong levels of physicality coupled with somewhat cartoonish characters meant that I could follow the plot even without catching all the words. But I probably missed many clever lines. The actors' singing was fine, but it wasn't written in a way to really show off anyone's singing skills - nobody stood out as a particularly good or bad singer in this show.

The acting was another story. I don't even know where to begin here. Every actor showed remarkable timing, humor, and even pathos despite the farcical nature of the play. Abbie Miller, as Grace Chastity, and Melanie Stevenson, as Max Jagerman, particularly stood out to me. Miller's character had the most complexity, and she handled it well, as both a convincing goody-goody and a sympathetic desperado, and I could understand her words better than most. Stevenson was a hilarious casting choice - let a petite, blonde young woman play the swaggering bully - but the real humor lay in her pitch-perfect gestures, vocal tone, and body language. I couldn't get enough of her performance and when she made a surprise return I was utterly entranced.

I must also nod to Alecia Jenkins, who played multiple parts with such charisma and physical humor she nearly stole the entire show. And to Harley DeBrooke as Peter Spankoffski and Riley O'Connor as Stephanie Lauter - their chemistry was undeniable and their relationship a true delight to watch as it unfolded. But every single actor, even with the smaller parts, was so utterly themselves - distinctive, knowable, and compelling - it was really striking. All the acting here was quite polished and professional.

By the end of the second act, I realized that I no longer felt on the outside, and a large part of the credit for that goes to the audience itself. I can't say I've ever been in a more supportive and engaged audience. Clearly, these young people were there to support their friends. So they cheered every scene with more enthusiasm than I would have expected, simply to show the performers support (which is a beautiful thing to behold). But they also were there for the story. This audience laughed long at every joke. They cheered when something good happened. In the dramatic moments, they gasped. At one tense moment in the plot I took my eyes off the stage and scanned the rows near me, to see at least 80% of the audience holding their hands to their mouths in horror, some shaking their heads, as if to say "no don't do it!" I couldn't stop a grin spreading across my face to see their shared responses, their investment in the play. It's such a joy to see young people all-in, on a lively production and on supporting one another. As the actors took their bows, I was clapping just as hard as the rest of the audience, and I knew I was a part of something larger. 

Even a farcical musical featuring at least five deaths, one of which is indeed death by wedgie, when in the right hands, can create that kind of theatrical magic. Maybe it's in the audience, maybe it's in the glitter, maybe it's in the script, maybe it's all of these... Wherever it dwells, the magic of good theater is one of my favorite things in the world: I live for that enchantment.

 

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Romeo and Juliet, Bear Theatre

Oklahoma!, Mill Mountain Theatre

Into the Woods, Attic Productions